Sunday, May 11, 2014

How does one separate the complete subject from the complete predicate by using a / in compound sentences? Example: Marion/read the paper. Please...

First, your “sample” is not a compound sentence. It is a simple clause with sentence punctuation (capital letter and period). There is no reason to separate the subject from the predicate with a / (called a solidus). Secondly, the solidus’ function is ambiguous, according to the Chicago Manual of Style. It is mostly a visual device, not punctuation, and can take the place of a semicolon to emphasize a distinct parallel relationship between two...

First, your “sample” is not a compound sentence. It is a simple clause with sentence punctuation (capital letter and period). There is no reason to separate the subject from the predicate with a / (called a solidus). Secondly, the solidus’ function is ambiguous, according to the Chicago Manual of Style. It is mostly a visual device, not punctuation, and can take the place of a semicolon to emphasize a distinct parallel relationship between two clauses, thus:


                 Our moon is usually simply called “the moon”/ our sun is simply called “the sun.” But astronomers use more precise and exclusionary terms.


In a normal multi-clause sentence, the solidus should be avoided.  Your problem sentence --"The boys went to the park, but they didn't do anything." -- would not benefit from an insertion of a solidus in place of the comma, because the "but" is a conjunction that serves a purpose, to show a negation between two clauses. A solidus in place of "but" would change the meaning of the sentence.


However, if you are using the solidus as part of a grammatical exercise in recognizing and indicating complete subject and predicate, then you would use the solidus quite simply, like this:


  • The boys/went to the park, but they/didn't do anything.

No comments:

Post a Comment

What is the Exposition, Rising Action, Climax, and Falling Action of "One Thousand Dollars"?

Exposition A "decidedly amused" Bobby Gillian leaves the offices of Tolman & Sharp where he is given an envelope containing $1...